I've been critical of HBO and the makers of Game Change since it became clear that the film would focus solely on the McCain/Palin campaign which accounts for only the last twenty-five percent of the book upon which it is based. I felt that it would be almost like cynically doing a remake of Jaws from Mrs. Kintner’s perspective. For what it’s worth, I wasn’t a fan of the controversial 2009 book by John Heilemann and Mark Halperin. The authors don’t take sides. But, in my opinion, their journalism was sloppy. For instance, they refer to Barack Obama doing the opening of the “December 11 ABC broadcast of Monday Night Football.” However, when Obama made his appearance, Monday Night Football had switched networks to ESPN (other examples in my review here).
That director Jay Roach and company choose to center a film version of the book exclusively on the LOSING side seemed driven more by personal and political agendas than a desire to craft an engaging historical drama. It’s been claimed that the production team ultimately choose to focus on McCain and Palin both out of discomfort with the idea of depicting a sitting President in a TV movie and the fact that a Hillary Clinton character had already been portrayed in another HBO film, The Special Relationship. Fair enough. Nonetheless, Game Change, the book, was about the nomination and election of the first African American President who had to defeat the first truly viable female candidate (and presumptive nominee) in a contentious Democratic primary process. I cannot imagine a story more historic, compelling, or fascinating than that.
I’d also offer this sentence taken from the book’s afterword: “It was Obama who was at the heart of Game Change.” Yet, Obama isn’t a character in the HBO movie. Res ipsa loquitur.
That said, the film deserves to be judged its own merits. So, I took a deep breath, cleared my head, and watched Game Change with an open mind (or as open as one can have). And, as political drama, it was only slightly better than the melodramatic mini-series on The Kennedys which came out in 2011. I repeat: only slightly.
...Full Post At Basket of Kisses.